PBP
Paul Murphy
I have a point of order.
Dail Éireann · 2022-11-30
Party shown is the one held on 2022-11-30, frozen at parse time — not the speaker's party today.
The Deputy has raised a matter of order but what he has asked is for the comments to be withdrawn and the Taoiseach is saying he will not withdraw them. Deputy McDonald raised the issue of poverty, and Social Justice Ireland also raised the same point. Social risks include risks to social cohesion, which relates to poverty, and risks associated with housing and sustainable development.
Will the Taoiseach confirm whether the funds allocated in the HSE budget under the progressing disability services, PDS, programme will be used to reinstate services in special schools? There remains a particular focus in the Cabinet subcommittee on health on the recruitment of people into the health and disability services.
Built by scoring every sentence in the debate on how distinctive its language is, then quoting the highest-scoring ones back word for word and in the order spoken. Nothing is paraphrased or invented — if a sentence appears here, it was said in the chamber. Drawn from 9,101 words across 110 contributions by 15 speakers.
How often each word appears across the whole debate, ranked by how distinctive it is to this debate rather than common to all parliamentary language.
All 24 contributions, start to finish, in the order they were made. The one you came here for is highlighted.
I have a point of order.
Let us see if it is a point of order.
Yesterday during Taoiseach's Questions, the Taoiseach said that People Before Profit-Solidarity Deputies were "puppets" for Putin's regime. I believe this to be an abuse of privilege and disorderly. It is a very serious allegation for a Taoiseach to make about Opposition Members of Parliament that they are agents of a foreign state, particularly a state like Russia.
That is not a point of order. The Deputy is entitled to raise the matter but what is he asking?
I am asking for the remark to be withdrawn in light of People Before Profit's very consistent record of opposition to Putin, the fact it is our co-thinkers who are in prison in Russia for opposing Putin's invasion of Ukraine and, while Bertie Ahern was shaking hands with Putin-----
No, we will not go into a discussion.
-----we were opposing the invasion of Chechnya.
The Deputy is asking for the comments to be withdrawn.
Yes.
This Parliament is the last bastion of democracy and free speech. The Deputies opposite feel free to make all sorts of assertions and allegations against Government Members on a consistent basis, whether we are puppets of oil and gas or of NATO, which is a constant assertion of Deputy Murphy and others. I will always retain the right to speak freely in this House. The far left does not get the right to frame the narrative in this Chamber. I will not withdraw it.
So the Taoiseach is not withdrawing that Opposition Members of Parliament are agents of a foreign power? That is incredibly authoritarian.
Thank you, Deputy. We are not having a debate.
It is genuinely quite chilling that the Taoiseach feels able to discount what we say and attempt to smear us by saying we are agents for Putin with no evidence whatsoever.
I have shown some flexibility on this. The Deputy has raised it-----
It is very serious. It is a real diminishing of democratic rights.
Thank you.
The Taoiseach is accusing Opposition Deputies-----
Deputy, we will not continue-----
-----because they do not go along with the Taoiseach's agenda of militarisation, of being agents of Putin.
Thank you, Deputy. Resume your seat.
It is quite shameful.
The Deputy has raised a matter of order but what he has asked is for the comments to be withdrawn and the Taoiseach is saying he will not withdraw them. There the matter rests for the moment. We will move on.
What remedy is there to be?
No, the issue has been dealt with at this point. The question has been asked and the comments have not been withdrawn. I am moving on to ceisteanna don Taoiseach.