◎ OireachtasDB

Seanad Éireann · 2024-04-24

Court Proceedings (Delays) Bill 2023: Committee and Remaining Stages

CC Pat Casey · Labour Panel · Acting Chairperson

Party shown is the one held on 2024-04-24, frozen at parse time — not the speaker's party today.

Summary of this debate

Auto-generated

The section creates the right for people to be compensated in circumstances where there is a breach of their right to have proceedings dealt with "within reasonable time". I know that later in this section, there is an expansive definition in section 11(4) of what factors will be considered for what constitutes "reasonable time". The Bill obviously does not concretely or definitively define "reasonable time" because it will depend on each case, nor does it define what the compensation means.

Will the Minister of State give an indication of what he would consider to be a reasonable time, even as an average time, or what he would consider to be reasonable compensation in the event of a breach under section 11(1)? It would not be appropriate for me to give any indication as it might be taken as an indication of what should be granted in a particular set of circumstances.

Built by scoring every sentence in the debate on how distinctive its language is, then quoting the highest-scoring ones back word for word and in the order spoken. Nothing is paraphrased or invented — if a sentence appears here, it was said in the chamber. Drawn from 277 words across 9 contributions by 4 speakers.

Most used terms in this debate

How often each word appears across the whole debate, ranked by how distinctive it is to this debate rather than common to all parliamentary language.

reasonable 6
indication 3
section 4
time 7
define 2
agreed 4
compensation 2
concretely 1
breach 2
proceedings 2
factors 2
definitively 1

The full debate

All 9 contributions, start to finish, in the order they were made. The one you came here for is highlighted.

FG Barry Ward

The section creates the right for people to be compensated in circumstances where there is a breach of their right to have proceedings dealt with "within reasonable time". I have two questions about "reasonable time". I know that later in this section, there is an expansive definition in section 11(4) of what factors will be considered for what constitutes "reasonable time". The Bill obviously does not concretely or definitively define "reasonable time" because it will depend on each case, nor does it define what the compensation means. I know there will be a proper assessment process for that. Will the Minister of State give an indication of what he would consider to be a reasonable time, even as an average time, or what he would consider to be reasonable compensation in the event of a breach under section 11(1)?

FF James Browne

As the Senator said, many factors will have to be taken into account. It would not be appropriate for me to give any indication as it might be taken as an indication of what should be granted in a particular set of circumstances. The complexity of the case, the conduct of the parties to proceedings and the importance of what is at stake will all be taken into account in making those decisions.

CC Pat Casey

When is it proposed to take Report Stage?

FF Robbie Gallagher

Anois.

CC Pat Casey

Is that agreed? Agreed.

CC Pat Casey this contribution

When is it proposed to take Fifth Stage?

FF Robbie Gallagher

Anois.

CC Pat Casey

Is that agreed? Agreed.

FF James Browne

I thank Senators. In my time as a junior Minister, this is the 12th Bill directly under my remit that has passed with the support and facility of the Seanad. I appreciate the work, effort and contributions of Senators.