CC
Mark Daly
I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Butler.
Seanad Éireann · 2024-07-10
Party shown is the one held on 2024-07-10, frozen at parse time — not the speaker's party today.
Second, through amendments to the Nursing Homes Support Scheme Act 2009, the Bill will widen the definition of those eligible to be considered as a family successor to a family farm or productive business assets under the nursing homes support scheme. Third, through an amendment to the Mental Health Act 2001, the Bill will change the length of time a person can serve on a mental health tribunal operated by the Mental Health Commission from the current term of three years to five years.
The first amendment to the Health Act 2007 is the introduction of compliance notices to provide a more timely and proportionate tool for intervention by the chief inspector when there is a breach of regulations.
Built by scoring every sentence in the debate on how distinctive its language is, then quoting the highest-scoring ones back word for word and in the order spoken. Nothing is paraphrased or invented — if a sentence appears here, it was said in the chamber. Drawn from 887 words across 16 contributions by 3 speakers.
How often each word appears across the whole debate, ranked by how distinctive it is to this debate rather than common to all parliamentary language.
All 16 contributions, start to finish, in the order they were made. The one you came here for is highlighted.
I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Butler.
This legislation has three main aims. First, through amendments to the Health Act 2007, it will strengthen the regulatory framework for nursing homes and residential care facilities for people with disabilities and children, thereby driving improvements for those living in such facilities. These people are some of our most vulnerable citizens. It is vital that we have a robust system of regulation to ensure they are receiving safe and good-quality care. The provisions in the Bill will provide important new safeguards for residents in these services. As such, I am seeking Members' support to enable the Bill to be considered and agreed today by the Seanad and enacted in this legislative session. This will ensure the protections are put in place as soon as possible.
Second, through amendments to the Nursing Homes Support Scheme Act 2009, the Bill will widen the definition of those eligible to be considered as a family successor to a family farm or productive business assets under the nursing homes support scheme.
Third, through an amendment to the Mental Health Act 2001, the Bill will change the length of time a person can serve on a mental health tribunal operated by the Mental Health Commission from the current term of three years to five years.
I begin by focusing on amendments to the Health Act 2007. That Act established the Health Information and Quality Authority, HIQA, and the Office of the Chief Inspector of Social Services. It also provides for a scheme of registration and inspection of the residential services to which I referred and for the making of regulations and the setting of standards on safety and quality in respect of those services. The chief inspector of social services, who is the regulator of the services, monitors compliance with the regulations and standards. There are three substantive provisions in the Bill to enhance the chief inspector's enforcement powers.
In a recent annual overview report of monitoring and regulation of older persons services in 2022, the chief inspector noted that although there was good overall compliance in 2022, “there are regulations with consistently higher levels of non-compliance over a prolonged period”. For these instances, it is essential there are effective enforcement mechanisms in place.
The first amendment to the Health Act 2007 is the introduction of compliance notices to provide a more timely and proportionate tool for intervention by the chief inspector when there is a breach of regulations. This is provided for in section 16 of the Bill. Focused on bringing the provider into compliance, it complements the existing enforcement processes under the Act. At present, the chief inspector’s enforcement powers centre on placing restrictions, known as conditions, on a registration or, in extreme cases, cancelling a registration. The chief inspector herself has described these as “blunt instruments”. Compliance notices will provide for a more nuanced intervention focused on bringing a provider into compliance and driving service improvement.
The second enforcement provision relates to the power to enter and inspect premises. The chief inspector currently has the power to enter and inspect premises that are registered or are in the process of being registered. It is an offence to operate as a designated centre without being registered by the chief inspector. However, there is no explicit power for the chief inspector to enter premises which she suspects are operating as designated centres to establish if, in fact, this offence is being committed. To address this, the Bill provides for an amendment to the Health Act to provide a clear and unambiguous power for the chief inspector in this regard and will ensure the protections afforded to residents of registered centres are extended.
The third amendment will reduce the timeframe that service providers have to make representations or appeal a decision of the chief inspector for current enforcement processes under section 51 of the Act from 28 to 14 days. This is provided for in sections 7 to 9, inclusive, and 12 of the Bill. Importantly, the Bill also introduces new provisions on the periodic and systematic collection of key data from nursing homes, the sharing of the data with the Minister, HIQA and the HSE, where appropriate, and the publication of this data at aggregate level. As Senators will be aware, the majority of nursing homes are in private ownership and we currently do not have any centralised process for the systematic collection of key data. Access to good quality, collated data on a sectoral basis is crucial to supporting effective national policy-making. These provisions are to address the gap. I want to be clear that no individual’s data will be circulated.
I will now outline the changes proposed to the Nursing Homes Support Scheme Act 2009. The nursing homes support scheme, commonly known as the fair deal, is a system of financial support for those requiring long-term nursing home care. As Senators will be aware, I introduced an amendment to the scheme in 2021 which extended the three-year cap that applies to the applicant's principal private residence and to family farm and business assets where a “family successor” is appointed. This family successor must continue to run the farm or business for at least a period of six years and have at least consistently applied to run the family asset for at least three of the last five years. This was a very important change. However, since introducing these amendments, it became clear there is a small group of individuals with no close relatives who seek to benefit from this relief but cannot do so because they do not have a person who meets the eligibility criteria. This Bill extends eligibility to great-nieces, great-nephews and great-grandchildren, and first cousins and relatives in the grandparental lineage, which includes first cousins once, twice and thrice removed. There are also a number of minor technical amendments to the Nursing Homes Support Scheme Act to provide for more precise cross-referencing.
The Bill also provides for a relatively minor amendment to the Mental Health Act 2001. This is provided for in section 34 of the Bill. As Senators will be aware, drafting of a mental health Bill which will substantially reform our mental health legislation is at an advanced stage, with the intention of it being published during this session. However, there is one pressing amendment that I would like to bring forward now for practical reasons. This amendment will change the length of time a person can serve on a mental health tribunal operated by the Mental Health Commission from the current term of three years to five years. The Mental Health Commission will begin the recruitment process for tribunal members later this year. Including this amendment in this Bill rather than the forthcoming Mental Health Bill will allow the commission to plan now for the appointment of tribunal members for five years. Each tribunal member recruitment campaign costs the Exchequer in the region of €250,000 so this amendment will have an immediate positive impact on the public purse.
I commend the Bill to the House and look forward to hearing from the Senators.
I welcome the Minister of State. I want to put on record that she is probably one of the most progressive Ministers in the Government. She listens to people, she understands where they are coming from and she reacts. This legislation exactly embodies her approach to politics. Everything has unintended consequences and we sometimes have to deal with those unintended consequences. Everybody who has loved ones in facilities, whether nursing homes or facilities to look after people with disabilities, expects a certain standard and expects things to be done right. People are not expecting luxury but they are expecting the basics to be done right. It is the responsibility of the State to ensure that that happens and to have the proper checks and balances and inspections in place. We need to move to random unannounced inspections in all of these facilities, although I know that takes time. What is proposed in the Bill is a major step in the right direction and anyone with a sense of responsibility will endorse it wholeheartedly.
By and large, HIQA does a good job. It probably does too good a job at times, which does not favour it with some people. However, it does it for the right reasons and it is motivated by quality and standards. It is the Health Information and Quality Authority, at the end of the day.
The fair deal, by its very title, is fair. However, somebody living in County Kerry or County Clare who just has cousins and wants to leave their landholding to a cousin cannot benefit from the fair deal, which is unfair. What we are doing here is levelling the playing pitch and making it fair and inclusive so people do not feel vulnerable because they do not have immediate family, such as sons, daughters, nieces or nephews. The vulnerability that old people feel when they do not necessarily have that immediate circle can be very frightening. If there is a cousin who is close to them, who has been good to them, who they have grown up with and who they trust and love, that should be possible.
It is absolutely the right thing to do. We are here to do the right thing. We do not always get it right, as the Leas-Chathaoirleach and the Minister of State know, but we do our very best to get it right. The changes that the Minister of State is proposing to the Mental Health Bill are also extremely welcome. Overall, the reason we are taking all Stages of this Bill today is that we would be shocked if anybody had a problem with it, and nobody has.
I thank the Minister of State. If I do not see her in the meantime, I hope she gets some bit of a break during the recess because she well deserves it.
I thank Senator Conway for his contribution. To clarify with regard to the fair deal, this amendment applies when, for example, a bachelor farmer who needs the support of a nursing home wants to appoint a successor so the farm will stay within the family. The person appointed as a successor does not have to be the person who the farm is eventually left to in the will.
When is it proposed to take Committee Stage?
Now.
Is that agreed? Agreed.
When is it proposed to take Report Stage?
Now.
Is that agreed? Agreed.
When is it proposed to take Fifth Stage?
Now.
Is that agreed? Agreed.
I thank the Minister of State.
I propose that the House suspend until 4 p.m.
Is that agreed? Agreed.